The original poster of the topic mentioned that there was contention in his local gaming group whether or not to use the rule. He then goes on to say that he wanted all of our opinions and to give reasons why. So we did. Most people agreed with my argument, but some did not. And it produced quite the "discussion". lol!
I plan on talking about this thread, my arguments, and their counter-arguments in a post sometime in the next couple days. I think its an important discussion regarding RAW (Rules as Written), RAI (Rules as Intended), INAT, and GW FAQ rulings. You'll just have to wait until I post up Part Four of the BT 101 section though, as its nearly finished and on schedule for completion this evening. :)